The Math Checks Out: Proof is a Big Win for 2nd Gen

By Stephen Dubois

Losing a parent is devastating. Sadly, I have lost both of mine, and even more difficult was being present as a caregiver for their decline. Such is the situation for Catherine, the central character in David Auburn’s Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award-winning drama Proof. She is struggling with the grief of her father’s passing while adjusting to a life in which she is no longer needed as his caregiver. At the same time, she must contend with the unexpected arrival of others who challenge her familiar routines and force her to confront a future for which she may not be prepared.

Robert, the father, was a brilliant mathematician whose early work was so groundbreaking that it fundamentally changed the field. But had he continued that momentum later in life? Could there be unpublished gems hidden somewhere in the house, waiting to see the light of day? These are the questions occupying Hal, a graduate student and former student of Robert’s, who believes that somewhere among the 113 composition notebooks left behind by the mathematician lies one final piece of extraordinary work. Hal is given permission to examine the notebooks, but what he initially encounters appears to be little more than incoherent ramblings. Undeterred, he commits himself to reading every last one.

Tensions flare when Catherine’s sister Claire arrives. Claire has remained largely detached from their father’s final years, seemingly oblivious to the sacrifices Catherine has made in her own life, including leaving school and giving up much of her social life, to care for him.  Her condescension, so often cloaked in “good intentions,” is remarkably well captured in both the writing and the portrayal of her character. When Claire presumes to “help” Catherine by uprooting her to New York City and selling the family home, the friction on stage reaches an entirely new level.

Chris Cavenaugh’s scenic and lighting designs effectively establish the back porch of the Chicago home, where all the action takes place across different days, times, and years. The setting remains constant, yet the passage of time is seamlessly conveyed through fades to black. Meanwhile, the percolating electronic music in Mason Beggs’ sound design beautifully establishes the tone and atmosphere of the transitions.

But the real star of this production is Auburn’s stellar script. He manages to weave multiple layers into this story, encompassing family drama, sexism in academia, the complexities of love and trust, betrayal, and ultimately, hope. The dialogue is remarkably natural, never feeling contrived, and consistently manages to convey something meaningful while remaining authentic. If you’ve never seen the play or the film, I won’t spoil a thing, but Act One concludes with a game-changing revelation that sends the story soaring in an entirely new direction. There is a wonderful sense of anticipation during intermission, as you simply cannot wait to discover where it all leads.

The quartet of actors rises to the challenge as well.

Matt Witten portrays Robert with tenderness and sincerity. His moments of anger and frustration are particularly effective, capturing the unpredictable behavior of someone experiencing mental deterioration, when moments of agitation give way to his more familiar kindness. Although Robert appears in flashbacks and sometimes in Catherine’s imagination, he remains a central presence throughout the story, even in death.

Steven Maiseke, as Hal, captures the nerdy awkwardness of his earlier interactions before evolving into the more confident mannerisms of a late bloomer. His earnest nature makes him an appealing presence, and his growing confidence adds another dimension to the character.  He also skillfully walks the line between genuine affection and opportunism.

Anna Krempholtz is perfectly cast as Claire. We all either have this sibling or know someone who does: the one who swoops in after all the difficult times are over, armed with plans and ideas for how to save the day. She has an uncanny ability to assume she knows what’s best for everyone, rarely considering whether her version of “help” is actually wanted. Krempholtz captures this personality beautifully, making Claire both frustrating and entirely believable.

And in the lead, Lauren Farrow is extraordinary as Catherine. Her emotional ups and downs, tentative neuroses, grief, and mounting stress are all wonderfully portrayed. She brings tremendous depth to a character who is simultaneously vulnerable, fiercely independent, and struggling to find her footing in a world that has suddenly changed.

Director Kristin Bentley and Associate Director Leah Berst bring this production to life with an engaging pace and thoughtful staging, clearly inspiring the cast to deliver some wonderful performances.

In the end, we are left with something hopeful, yet deliberately ambiguous. Like the mathematical proof at the center of the story, not every answer is immediately apparent. But sometimes the possibility of what lies ahead is proof enough

Proof will be playing at the Shea’s Smith Theatre through December 6.  Tickets available at Sheas.org or Second Generation Theatre 2nd Gen Buffalo.

If you’re attending the Friday, November 20, stay for the post-performance panel discussion “Every Woman, All Things” with community representatives discussing caregiving and mental wellness.

Please note: Mental wellness and caregiving are central themes of this story, and Spectrum Health and Human Services is proud to co-sponsor this production. Help and hope are always available for individuals who need intervention and their caregivers, too. Immediate emergency support is available 24/7 by calling 988.