Once -once again – is Magical

“You cannot walk through life leaving unfinished love behind you.”

That’s the essence of the plaintive and lovely musical Once,  produced by MusicalFare Theatre and presented by Shea’s 710 Theatre.

I flat out loved this production, from the Irish pub set designed by Chris Cavanagh to the way director Randy Kramer used the whole house to frame the story, to Michael Oliver Walline’s precise and stunning choreography, and the sweet-sad-hopeful story itself.

A standout from MusicalFare’s 2018 season, this band is -literally – together again, and what a band it is under Theresa Quinn’s musical direction. There are plenty of familiar faces, not only the previous Once, but from MusicalFare’s productions of Million Dollar Quartet.  Composers Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova’s songs range from toe-tapping North Atlantic fiddle and jig to melodic and lilting ballads, all skillfully performed and woven into the story.

Ah, yes, the story: Steve Copps is the guy, an Irishman in Dublin, busking and working for his da’s vacuum repair shop and ready to give up on music. Then he meets the girl, (Renee Landrigan), a fellow musician who sees through the guy’s broken heart. She encourages him to connect with his music again. Along the way, she introduces him to her extended Czech family, including her mother (Theresa Quinn), and her daughter (the absolutely adorable Arden Kacala in her very first role). Philip Farugia is Billy, another Irishman trying to win the girl’s heart, and he’s hysterical as he pines for her and struggles to keep the community’s music store going.

When Copps and Landrigan sing, it’s pure magic. Their voices meld beautifully and the slightly eerily melodies flow against the wistful words of love that can be better…and it’s pure gold. They’re reprising their 2018 roles and maybe the passage of time added to the wisdom and heart they bring to their performances.

As poignant as the love story is, the comedic moments are a stitch and a half. Farugia’s Billy is all blunder and heart. John Kaczorowski as the bank manager who is also a wannabe musician lands some of the best lines of the night. Nick Stevens and Bob Mazierski get their share of laughs, too.

The music, though, is so powerful and evocative…and also downright fun as Katie Clark and Maggie Zindle play some dueling fiddles and Amy Jakiel joins in with some cello, too.

Once runs a little more than two hours (I didn’t want it to end) with a 15-minute intermission, to May 19. Find tickets and details at sheas.org.

CROWNS is Joyful Noise and Fashionable, too

Who hasn’t been told to “cover your head” to either protect or adorn your crowning glory? What we wear on our heads and why is at the heart of CROWNS, now onstage at MusicalFare Theatre until May 19.

Playwright Regina Taylor weaves Black American history, inspirational storytelling, and glorious Gospel music into a proud tale about finding your personal expression in an unexpected place. For Yolanda (Janae Leonard), this means she is transported from her native and beloved Brooklyn to her grandmother’s home in the south after an incident ends her brother’s life. In this new place, her rap music, flashy clothes, and bravado don’t fit this traditional culture. She learns, though, through her grandmother’s firm yet gentle hand, her church woman friends, their stylish hats and the things and people they represent.

This is a lively, joyous production that celebrates womanhood, faith, and a dash of fashion, too.  You’re immediately drawn in by Chris Cavanagh’s video and set design. There’s just enough video to add interest without a screen takeover and it’s very skillfully integrated into the set, which is elegantly curved to suggest a church layout. Then the music grabs your ears and doesn’t let go. Karen Saxon commands a keyboard that goes from orchestra to piano to church organ and back again, backed up by Preston Brown at the drums. And when the women of the church start singing, hold on to your hats, the are marvelous. Each has a story and song to share about how they are living their truth and are ready to share their life lessons with Yolanda. Danielle N. Green, Latosha Jennings, Zhanna Reed, Ember Tate-Steele, and Davida Evette Tolbert raise their voices in high praise and encourage the audience to clap and sway and join their journeys. Director Thembi Duncan and choreographer Naila Ansari had the cast across the stage and up the stairs to immerse the audience in the whole experience. Through it all, hats came off and came back on and it’s all glorious. The poignant message sings through: a hat is more than a fashion statement. It’s history and protection and a display of self, with humility and pride. It’s a personal crown of triumph and a reminder to share your love.

There is an irresistible joy in this show that makes every element of it uplifting and wonderful. CROWNS runs for just under two hours with a 15-minute intermission. Find details and tickets at www.musicalfare.com. Amen!

Beautiful is an Understatement at MusicalFare

Beautiful The Carole King Musical now on stage at MusicalFare to March 24 is, indeed, beautiful in every way. It celebrates the early days of Carole King’s illustrious career, first as a songwriter with her husband Gerry Goffin and then as a solo singer-songwriter. She was – and still is – an icon in pop music.

STOP: By the time you finish reading this review, you may miss your opportunity, so go to www.musicalfare.com right now to grab your tickets.

OK, resume reading now.

Part jukebox musical and part overview of how pop music was made back in the day, Beautiful features a cast of 18 with a superb back up band led by music director Theresa Quinn.

It’s the young and ambitious Carole who opens the show by nudging mom (Debbie Pappas Sham) away from the family’s upright piano so she can finish writing the song she wants to ‘sell’ to storied producer Don Kirshner (John Kaczorowski). He knows a pop hit when he hears it and soon makes space in his stable of writers for Carole and boyfriend-about-to-be-husband Goffin. They start churning out the hits for the biggest names in ‘60s pop. Along the way they meet rivals/best pals Cynthia Weil and Barry Mann where they grow as artists and then grow apart as a couple.

Maria Pedro and Sean Ryan are out front as King and Goffin and they shine. Gretchen Didio and Josh Wilde are Weil and Mann with the perfect combination of peppy and nebbish. I loved this dynamic. The rest of the cast are the radio stars who made these songs soar. David P. Eve, Jake Hayes, El Tyner, and Derrian Brown are The Drifters with that cool sound, snappy wardrobe and precision choreography.  Brett Jackson and Marc Sacco (love how their voiceparts cross) are the Righteous Brothers with Jackson doing double duty as Neil Sedaka. Lily Jones, Janae Leonard, Timiyah Love, and Ember Tate are the Shirelles. Sacco comes back as Lou Adler, the producer who made King’s 1971 album Tapestry the staple in every teen girl’s record collection. King’s legacy endures but this story stops telling at Tapestry’s rise to fame, when King is empowered by confidence as an artist and a performer.

Director Randy Kramer must have had a blast with this cast and crew. Dyan Burlingame built a set that took you back to the funky shapes and colors of the era. The sisters Drozd nailed the look with Kari’s teeny bopper chic and granny gowns for Carole and sophisticated stylings for Cynthia and shiny satins for the performers, and Susan’s hairdos from curly to sleek.

Sound was paramount here and Chris Cavanagh had it all in good balance. For once I was glad to not have his clever projections: this was a show about people and their music and the staging and music was all your needed to revel in this experience.

Am I overselling? Nope.  Just get a ticket and before the overture is over, you’ll say to yourself “Something Tells Me I’m Into Something Good.”

Beautiful The Carole King Musical runs a little more than two hours with an intermission. And I’m serious about grabbing your tickets now. Don’t wait until “It’s Too Late.”

Showtune Showcases Jerry Herman Masterpieces

Showtune is currently on the MusicalFare Theatre Premier Cabaret stage for only a few more performances, so if you’re a fan of Jerry Herman’s exquisite music, book your table now.

The show is replete with the songs you love to hear and hum: the haunting “Time Heals Everything” from Mack & Mabel, the cheeky “Bosom Buddies” from Mame, the lovely “Song on the Sand” from La Cage Aux Folles” are beautifully performed by powerhouse singers Anne DeFazio, Gregory Gjurich, Mary Coppola Gjurich, Stevie Kemp, Austin Marshall, and Eric Deeb Weaver with Stephen Piotrowski at the piano.

MusicalFare is calling this a Cabaret Musical, meaning it’s performed in the lobby Cabaret space and it’s not an engaged cabaret-style show, and nor is it a full-blown musical from the mainstage. This hybrid means that there are minimal props and a costume change. It’s a format that just isn’t for me. The usual performance platform was tricked out with a small stage façade outline with white lights and two side doors to allow the actors to flow about the now small-ish stage. During some numbers, the actors carried some props and there were some nods to costumes and accessories. It worked for songs like “A Little More Mascara” and Deeb Weaver’s interpretation was well done, down to the transformation of dressing in drag. I didn’t need to see actual ribbons down Kemp’s back, however, when she sang “Ribbons Down My Back;” her lilting, lovely voice and wistful presentation put me in that Hello, Dolly-era setting well enough. Same could be said about “Movies Were Movies” which started Act 2. Greg Gjurich is born for this number (he’s performed it a few times in Gentlemen Prefer DIVA presented by O’Connell and Company.) He didn’t need a faux camera and clapboard to remind us that he’s portraying a filmmaker.  In other words, this show could have let Jerry be Jerry and just have the cast sing the songs. Herman’s music/lyrics are that outstanding and evocative.

A couple of the highlights were the less familiar tunes. Kemp does wonderful things with Shalom, from Herman’s first musical Milk and Honey. “I Don’t Want to Know” from Dear World (how prescient Herman was to write about environmental impacts back in ’69!) were just grand.

The singers were truly spectacular and the solo piano accompaniment was perfection. Keep an eye out for Marhsall: he’s still in college and his performance was mature, nuanced, and outstanding.

Showtune runs just under two hours with an intermission for a good stretch and a refill. The show closes January 28 so get there and lose yourself in well-crafted words and wonderful music. Find details at musicalfare.com.

Oh My God, You Guys! Legally Blonde at MusicalFare

I know you’ve read this from me before, but it bears repeating: I’m not a fan of movies on stage. Sigh, they just keep coming. The latest is Legally Blonde The Musical, on stage at MusicalFare Theatre to December 10.

While I dislike the trend, It’s not the fault of this immensely talented cast or crew. There is a lot to like about this production, starting with Michael Oliver-Walline’s choreography (he’s also the director). Every dance sequence is energetic and joyous and makes you just want to jump up to join in.

Chris Cavanagh uses pink (our heroine Elle Wood’s “signature color”) on the set to set the tone for this tale of a blonde and bouncy California girl who wants to follow her ex-boyfriend to Harvard Law School (“like that’s hard,” she chirps) to win him back.

Gretchen Didio is Elle and she is perfectly perky as she naively dances her way into the Harvard Law admissions team’s hearts.  What’s a college girl without her sorority sisters and Anna Fernandez, Sabrina Kahwaty, Kristen-Marie Lopez, Kayla McSorley, and Alexandria Watts shriek, squeal, and selfie like a loyal Delta Nu. 

Elle quickly discovers that life at Harvard doesn’t have the warmth of Malibu sunshine. Classmates like Vivienne (Amanda Funicello) – who is also her ex’s new love interest – outshine her in class and humiliate her socially.  Even her CA beau Warner (Alex Anthony Garcia) is different here. She forms new connections with fledgling attorney Emmett (wonderfully played by Sean Ryan) and manicurist Paulette (Nicole Cimato) and begins to see herself in a new light. She also finds her strength dealing with sleazeball Professor Callahan (Marc Sacco).

The breakthrough moment is when Elle is part of a trial team and her observations contribute to a verdict on the right side of the law. The stage version (again, no fault of this cast/crew) doesn’t have the punch of the movie. Instead there’s an ensemble song which may have sounded witty to songwriters Laurence O’Keefe and Neil Benjamin a few years back, but I found rather….unappealing.

It’s fitness instructor/wife of a dead rich guy Brooke (Gabriella Jean McKinley) who’s on trial and don’tchaknowit, she’s a Delta Nu like Elle. McKinley rocks this role and her Act II “Whipped Into Shape” song is a tribute to her vocal and fitness training as she jumps rope and sings…perfectly, on pitch, and in step. She is amazing.

The stage version tries to make the most out of some of the movie’s funniest scenes, like when Paulette is trying to catch the eye of delivery man Kyle (Bobby Cooke) and Elle teaches her to “bend and snap.” This scene is pure gold and Cimato and especially Cooke make the most of it.

My ears detected some opening night troubles with the sound, music, and some singers which I’m sure are well ironed out.

All told, it’s a fun night of theatre. It’s hard not to compare it with the film which is ubiquitous on most cable movie channels so go in with an open mind. I’d be remiss if I didn’t give a shout out to the little doggo with the duel role of Bruiser (Elle’s pet) and Dewey (Paulette’s pooch). What a good pup!

Legally Blonde The Musical runs under two hours with an intermission to December 10. It’s a fun girl’s night out. Find tickets and info at www.musicalfare.com.

Guys and Dolls Lives On

There’s a lot to love about a classic musical.  The familiarity is a cozy hug from someone who just plain out loves you. Even when (OK, sometime especially when) the story is a little far-fetched and the dialogue is dated, a great score will never go out of style, so these old chestnuts will always entertain you. That’s how I feel about Guys and Dolls, on stage now at MusicalFare Theatre. The program notes (yes, a real paper program was put in my hands and I couldn’t be happier!) calls this production “fresh and innovative” and major props go to director Chris Kelly for selecting a diverse and interesting cast. The rest of the show is pure nostalgia.

Chris Cavanagh’s set was simple and props were limited, so the whole show rested on the beautifully costumed (the good work of Kari Drozd) shoulders of the cast. Susan Drozd styled this group to red-lipped perfection.

The best part of this show is Frank Loesser’s killer score, hands down. Music director Theresa Quinn led a spare yet solid band (keyboards, drums, trumpet, bass and reeds) and this simplicity against the vocal talents of the cast let every note shine. There were a couple rocky minutes at the start of the show during the iconic “Fugue for Tin Horns,” but I’d write that off as maybe some audio challenges on this particular night. The delightful surprise of the opening vocal trio (Thomas Evans as Rusty Charlie and Anthony Lazzaro as Benny Southstreet) is Davida Evette Tolbert as Nicely Nicely. She was as Zoot suited as the next guy with her flash of long-red-painted nails giving her flair. 

The story unfolds as it always had: a group of professional gamblers is searching for a place for their next crap game. It’s always good ol’ reliable Nathan Detroit (well played by John Kaczorowski) who makes the arrangements and he’s rolling snake eyes.  Officer Brannigan (Rolando Martin Gomez) is on to him and the do-gooders from the Save a Soul Mission keep marching by to, well, save the sinners’ souls. Leading the pack is Sarah Brown (Sarah Blewett) who is eager to keep the mission viable, but a lack of saved souls is putting the site in danger. High roller Sky Masterson (in a stand-out performance by Alex Anthony Garcia) woos her with a whirlwind dinner date to Cuba and their three back-to-back numbers (“If I Were a Bell,” “My Time of Day,” and “I’ve Never Been in Love Before”) were dazzling. Garcia’s voice was spectacular as he gave some interesting nuance to phrasing and vocal styling.

There were other great musical moments, too. Maria Pedro as the sniffling Miss Adelaide gives her laments with conviction and she and Kaczorowski milk every moment in “Sue Me.” It’s Bobby Cooke’s sweet and simple styling of “More I Cannot Wish You” that stole my heart. It’s a tender moment and Cooke’s rendition was pure loveliness.

Of course, Jimmy Janowski as Big Jule, the man with the big hat and high voice, is a hoot and a half.

All told, Guys and Dolls is a fun night out with music you’ve heard forever (yes, my grandpa used to sing me “I Love You a Bushel and a Peck”) and will always love. Full disclosure: a family emergency forced my departure three tunes from the end.

Guys and Dolls is onstage to October 8 and runs a sold two hours and some change with a 15-minute intermission.  Secure your tickets at http://www.musicalfare.com.

Twelfth Night Plays On at MusicalFare

Everyone loves the classic “mistaken identity” plotline. You know, the one where  you wear  your twin brother’s clothes because you think he died when you were both shipwrecked, but you’re really a woman so when people think you’re a man and another woman starts to fall in love with you, you just go along with it.  Meanwhile, your twin bro thinks you’re the dead one and adopts a new identity but is wearing clothes that matches yours. There’s love. There’s betrayal.  Hijinx ensues! So that’s the gist of Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, but MusicalFare’s production adds a killer score and one of the best ensemble casts you can imagine. In other words, “if music be the food of love, play on!”

Conceived by Kwame Kwei-Armah with outstanding music and lyrics by Shaina Taub (she also gave a contemporary version of As You Like It the same treatment), this show is pure fun from start to finish. There’s still some Elizabethan-speak for authenticity, but this is contemporary, fast-paced, and an absolute delight.

Director Susan Drozd gave the MusicalFare production a unique touch, too: Feste the fool (Maria Pedro) opens the show with an Emcee/warm up schtick that is actually quite charming. Better a witty fool than a foolish wit, indeed. Then she straps on an accordion (songwriter Taub’s instrument of choice) and the musical voyage to Illyria begins. First, the music. Taub’s score is great, with a funk-pop-jazz vibe that is totally ear-appealing. It’s the stuff that is in music director/keyboardist Theresa Quinn’s wheelhouse. Larry Albert, Jim Celese, John Maguda, Jimmy Runfola, and Jim Runfola kick in on guitar, drums, trumpet, bass, and reeds respectively. Add in some great trombone riffs from cast member Ricky Needham, too (watching him move and play and sing reminds me of watching Jimmy Pankow from iconic band Chicago). Stand out songs were the peppy “Word on the Street,” the heartfelt and hummable “This is My Beloved,” the absolute radio hit potential “Is This Not Love” and the 11-o’clock anthem “I Am She.”  

It’s truly a stellar cast with Gabriella Jean McKinley and her power-diva vocals as Viola, Augustus Donaldson twinning as Sebastian, Louis Colaicovo  as the malevolent Malvolio, Stevie Jackson, Lisette DeJesus, Thomas Evans, Alex Anthony Garcia, Christian Hines, Kristen-Marie Lopez, Nick Lama, Dave Spychalski, Ember Tate, and Daniel Torres, singing and dancing like nobody’s business. The sign language choreography (by Melissa VanOsch) was an unexpected and way cool touch to the closing numbers.

So dispel your recollection of 10th grade honors English and forget about the straight-laced Elizabethan romps of past productions. This version of Twelfth Night is the one you’ll remember as you search through YouTube to find your favorite songs again. Hasten to make way to MusicalFare before it’s curtains on August 6: procure tickets at Musicalfare. Huzzah!

This is two hours with a 15-minute intermission to refill your MusicalFare sippy cup with the signature Toby cocktail (spoiler alert, it’s good).

Kinky Boots Raises You Up at Shea’s 710

Well, Buffalo is a factory town. Road Less Traveled’s recent production of Sweat gave us a grim reminder of what happens when a factory is on the brink. Suffice it to say, that Buffalo hasn’t seen the likes of Price & Son, the factory at the soul of Kinky Boots, MusicalFare Theatre’s production on stage at Shea’s 710 Theatre.

The story is based on an actual situation which happened in the UK in 1999: a family-owned maker of men’s dress shoes was about to go under when the owner discovered an under-served market for fine footware: drag queens. Tweaking the business plan kept workers on at the plant and restored profitability. This inspired the 2005 film Kinky Boots written by Geoff Deane and Tim Firth which then inspired Harvey Firestein to write the stage show with Cyndi Lauper writing original music and lyrics in 2013.  As I am wont to say, I usually don’t care for movies on stage, but this show is so irrepressible, it would be hard to dislike it.  Most importantly, there’s a powerful message of inclusion, acceptance, personal freedom, and self-love that shines through, particularly in Lauper’s Tony-winning lyrics.

Everything about this production was a delight, from the cast, to the band, to the choreography and plenty of stage magic. The show opens as Papa Price (John Fredo) is extolling the virtue of traditional footware to his young son Charlie (Daniel Pitirri), while Simon’s Papa (Vincenzo McNeill) is less than impressed with his son Simon’s (Oliver Parzy-Sanders) fascination with a bright red pair of pumps. Fast forward a bunch of years, and the young adult Charlie (Steve Copps) doesn’t think that shoes are the most beautiful thing in the world, so (much like George Bailey in It’s a Wonderful Life), he leaves the family business behind for big city life. His father’s death draws him home. A chance encounter with grown up Simon, now drag queen Lola (Lorenzo Shawn Parnell)   and a conversation with one of his employees (Bethany Burrows) who is about to lose her job, spark the idea to build shoes that support a manly body type when he’s in drag. From here, the story is a really a journey, and it’s a beautiful one.

The entire cast is stellar, from the young actors playing Charlie and Simon/Lola as children to the shoe factory workers who rally to make sharp and spiky boots where there’s plenty of sex in the heel. Look and listen for Artie Award recognized actors like Charmagne Chi, Dan Urtz, Doug Weyand, and Dave Spychalski among the factory workers, and Lola’s back up singers/dancers known as the Angels in drag Marc Sacco, Johnny Kiener, Collin McKee, and David Pieffer.

Copps wins hearts as he stumbles – literally – down a non-traditional path, and it’s Parnell who puts the soul in boot making with the poignant “I’m Not My Father’s Son” and “Hold Me in Your Heart” ballads. Beautiful musical moments for sure. In between the powerful messages about inclusion and belonging there are delectably in-your-face proofs about the pure joy of loving what you do, who you are, and who you’re with on the journey. As the song says, “you change the world when you change your mind.”

Kinky Boots runs under two hours with a 15-minute intermission, to May 21, which includes some extra performances. Grab tickets fast at sheas.org.

Disaster! Feels So Good at MusicalFare

A pretty buttoned up reporter. A nightclub owner with daddy issues. A ditzy disco diva and her twin children. A nun with a gambling problem. What happens when they meet on a poorly constructed off-shore casino with a problematic pier? It’s sure to be a Disaster!  Disaster!, the brain-child of Broadway divo Seth Rudetsky, is making its WNY premier at MusicalFare Theatre and it’s a hoot. It’s a jukebox musical with ‘70s tunes and satirical nod to all the disaster films that kept us going to movie theatres (remember those?) before we headed off to Uncle Sam’s to dance the night away on the light floor.

The story pretty simple: Tony wants to make a bundle on a floating casino so he cuts some corners on the whole safety thang. His lady friend Jackie will be the lounge singer as long as she keeps her kids out of trouble. He hires a waiter with the moves and his friend who aspires to be the other waiter with moves and they welcome passengers like Maury and Shirl who just want to have a little fun. Of course, a local nun is convinced there’s onboard gambling so she meets guests at the dock with a cheerful “you’ll burn in hell” message. And there’s scientist on board who knows that too much tango hustling can cause tidal waves if you “Knock On Wood” too many times. Of course.

Well, if the story sounds a little thin, the killer list of fun and familiar tunes more than makes up for it. So does this sparkling (and large) cast. Stand outs are Kelly Copps as Jackie the singer. She softens her speaking voice to an impish whisper (think of Georgette on “The Mary Tyler Moore Show”) but boy, she’s at full-power when she sings “Saturday Night” and “I Will Survive.”  Ricky Needham is Chad the waiter, sporting a wig that looks pretty much like the hair I had in my high school senior photo. He’s shakin’ his groove thing until he runs into his ex and then the sparks and sequins fly. He does a fabulous job on the Jigsaw hit “Sky High.”  Kevin Craig is the scientist who can prove that disaster is coming and I was laughing out loud at his ‘balance beam’ walk to “Nadia’s Theme.”  Gabriella Jean McKinley is the disco queen (with her designer doggie-in-a-bag) poured into spandex and doing a fabulous job with my fave tune from ’74 “Come to Me.” Emily Yancey is a riot as the nun, and Arin Lee Dandes – everyone’s favorite eternal child – is amazing as Jackie’s twins. Yes, she plays both kids with some theatre magic and sleight of hand/s. You just have to see it. Jon May and Jennifer Mysliwy were adorable as sweethearts Maury and Shirl and their ‘bump’ to Orleans’ “Still the One” took me back to a high school dance.

Directed by Randy Kramer with Robin Barker’s choreography, every moment of Disaster! Is replete with a sparkle, sass, site gags, and tongue-in-cheek bits that were more than fine. The sisters Drozd captured the era with point perfect hair, makeup and styles (my arches tensed all over again at the site of all those platform shoes), and Chris Cavanagh’s set, lighting projection and sound designs took us back to a shinier, glittery time. Theresa Quinn and the band pulled it all together with a great hit list of tunes. I knew every word. And I sang along with absolutely no shame.

I loved the humor, the details, and all that great music. Disaster! Is a success! Get there before it all goes down May 14. And yes, I wish I still had my red leather cork-platform sling backs to wear.

Disaster! runs a little over two hours with an intermission. I love MusicalFare’s clever and informative pre-show videos when I can hear them and I still miss a real paper playbill, but since I heard a hilarious take on Chicago’s “25 or 6 to 4,” you’re forgiven this time.

Sir Andrew’s Back in Town at MusicalFare

It takes a lot of stage presence to command a stage solo for more than an hour. And that’s exactly what Leah Berst does in Tell Me on a Sunday, onstage now at MusicalFare Theatre.

Berst has the power (and the chops) to sing her way through this Andrew Lloyd Webber and Don Black one-woman song cycle. They wrote it in 1979, post Webber’s Evita, and the original plan was for it to be a TV program. Perhaps Sir Webber was still Rainbow High-weary; outside of the title song and the familiar tune “An Unexpected Song,” the melodies are Webber-predictable and the story is fairly flat.

That’s not to say that Berst isn’t commanding and outstanding on stage: she’s fantastic. It’s the script that doesn’t rise to her level, sadly.

In brief, Berst’s unnamed character leaves her home in the UK for New York City and love. That love fails, so it’s on to someone new. And then someone new and younger And then someone in California.. And then someone new and married. In between, she’s emailing her mum, getting angry at girlfriends, endeavoring to earn her green card, while remaining a hopeful romantic.

There are some fun moments. The repetitive “It’s Not the End of the World” (If I Lose Him, If He’s Younger, If He’s Married) is clever. Berst pours her heart into “Come Back With The Same Look in Your Eyes” and it’s lovely. Her self-righteous anger in “Let Me Finish” is classic break up material. She maintains her optimism with “Dreams Never Run On Time.” Le sigh…

Therese Quinn assembled a fine back up band, with Larry Albert on guitar, Jim Celeste on drums, Mike Moser on bass, Jim Runfola on woodwinds, and Gail Bauser playing cello which is absolutely lovely against Berst’s high range voice. Chris Cavanagh’s set is eye appealing and he uses some fun videos that help move the flimsy story along. It was fun to see other actors in video cameos, almost like a “Where’s Waldo of Buffalo Theatre.”

What I appreciate best about this show is its brevity: an hour and 10 minutes with no intermission. If COVID did one good thing for theatre, it’s the new emphasis on shorter productions. The Theatre Companion and I arrived early enough to enjoy good conversation in the Cabaret and lingered a few minutes post-show to enjoy Quinn and Randy Kramer getting four hands on the piano. It’s always great fun at MusicalFare.

I’m no fan of digital programs (I know…it saves money, it is contact-less, more to read on your own time…I get it), but I do love MusicalFare’s super creative use of the in-theatre video monitors before the program. Nell Mohn, Director of Strategic Development, was informative and entertaining in her video which explained the valueand need for fundraising. As a recovering fundraiser, I love and respect her enthusiasm for this challenging work.

Tell Me on a Sunday runs to March 19: visit musicalfare.com for tickets and details.